Amityville is one of the smaller villages on the Great South Bay, about 9,500 people in 2.5 square miles at the western edge of Suffolk County. A surprising share of that area, about 0.42 square miles, is water, and the village averages only around 20 feet above sea level. Settlers from Huntington came here in the 1600s for the salt hay that grew along the bay, the community adopted the name Amityville around 1846 and incorporated in 1894, and by the early 1900s it was a summer destination with large bayfront hotels and big homes.
Those roots on the water define the village's flood risk, and its stock of older houses adds plumbing and roof problems of its own. The Restoration Job does not perform repairs; it is a no-charge line that refers callers to local companies. Call (888) 317-9980 at any hour and we will connect you with an independent provider that works in Amityville.
How the call works: when you call (888) 317-9980, The Restoration Job connects you with an independent restoration provider that serves Amityville. That provider inspects the damage, explains the scope and quotes the work. The Restoration Job doesn't perform restoration itself. Read our referral disclosure.
Living on the Great South Bay's Edge
The village's southern boundary is the Great South Bay, with Sand Island just offshore from Amityville Beach and reachable only by boat. Beyond the bay, barrier islands such as Jones Beach Island and Fire Island take the brunt of the open ocean, but a strong coastal storm can still push bay water up into low streets, yards and basements. During Sandy in 2012, Suffolk County ordered evacuations of storm surge zones in the Town of Babylon, which includes Amityville, and roughly 100,000 homes were damaged across Long Island.
Bay flooding brings salt, sediment and sewage into a house. Cleanup typically means removing soaked finishes and insulation above the waterline, washing and disinfecting the framing, and checking heating systems and electrical components before use. Thorough flood cleanup at that stage is what makes a sound rebuild possible.
Older Houses From the Resort Era Onward
The large homes built during Amityville's resort years, and houses from the decades that followed, often have older plumbing, plaster walls and roofs that have been repaired more than once. In those houses, leaks often travel a long way before showing up. Water from a second-floor bath can run down inside a wall and appear in the basement, and a failed roof flashing can stain a ceiling two rooms from the actual leak.
When the source is not obvious, a restoration provider will use moisture meters and sometimes thermal imaging to trace the water before opening walls. Careful water damage repair in an older home aims to dry and save original plaster and woodwork where possible and replace only what has failed.

Cloudbursts, Nor'easters and Wind-Driven Rain
Rain events can be as damaging as surge. In August 2014, Islip, a short drive east, set New York's 24-hour rainfall record with 13.57 inches, and flooding closed stretches of the Southern State Parkway and Sunrise Highway. Storms like that overload drainage in a low, flat village quickly. Nor'easters add days of wind-driven rain that finds weak spots in windows, siding and chimneys.
After a storm, walk the house and check:
- Attic sheathing and insulation under the most exposed roof slopes
- Ceilings under dormers, skylights and chimneys
- Window sills and the wall below on the windward side
- Basement walls, floor drains and the area around the water heater
Missing shingles, broken windows or downed limbs on the roof call for prompt storm damage cleanup, including tarping to keep the next rain out.
Preparing for Storm Season in the Village
Suffolk County's Office of Emergency Management offers an interactive storm surge zone map, a shelter locator and Suffolk Alert notifications; hurricane season runs from June 1. Find out your zone before a storm is forecast. Keep important papers above the first floor, raise stored items off the basement and garage floor, and photograph your rooms and belongings now so you have a record if you need to file a claim. Standard homeowners policies do not cover rising floodwater, which requires a separate flood policy, and new policies usually carry a waiting period before coverage starts.

Bay Humidity and Mold in Older Walls
Humid summers along the bay slow drying, and thick old walls hold moisture longer than modern drywall. Mold tends to appear behind wallpaper, under carpet, in closets on outside walls and in basements. Dry wet materials within a day or two, run dehumidifiers, and keep an eye out for musty smells that persist. Larger or recurring growth calls for professional removal with containment. The same bayfront conditions affect homes in neighboring Lindenhurst.
Amityville Neighborhoods and Surrounding Towns
Calls come in from across Amityville, including:
- The Triangle
- Ocean Avenue
The same line also serves nearby communities such as:
- Copiague
- North Amityville
- East Massapequa
- Massapequa
- Lindenhurst
- Babylon
Questions From Amityville Property Owners
Is Amityville likely to flood in a hurricane?
Parts of the village close to the Great South Bay and at low elevation are vulnerable to storm surge, and Suffolk County ordered evacuations of surge zones in the Town of Babylon during Sandy. Higher blocks farther north face less tidal risk but can still see heavy-rain flooding. Check the county's storm surge zone map and FEMA's flood maps for your specific address.
My house is on the Nassau side of the line. Does that matter?
The village borders East Massapequa, which is in Nassau County. Emergency management, permits and alerts follow the county and municipality where your property sits, so Amityville residents look to the village and Suffolk County, while East Massapequa residents deal with Nassau County and the Town of Oyster Bay. Restoration providers often work on both sides of the county line.
Can plaster walls in an older Amityville house be saved after a leak?
In many cases, provided the water was clean and drying begins right away. Plaster on lath handles brief wetting better than drywall, and it can often be dried in place and patched. Plaster that has separated from the lath, or walls soaked by bay or sewage water, usually needs to come out. Ask the provider to show you moisture readings and explain the reasoning.
Who should I call first after a flood?
If there is any danger from electricity or gas, call 911 or the utility first. Next, contact your insurer to open a claim, then call (888) 317-9980 to be connected with an independent restoration provider in the area. Photograph damage before anything is removed, and keep samples of flooring or materials if your adjuster asks for them.
